By Dr. Joshua S. Greer
For the Titans, the No. 4 overall pick is not just about selecting the best available player. It is about making the right decision for where the franchise currently stands. If there is no clear, franchise-altering talent on the board, forcing a selection at that spot can create more long-term issues than it solves. This is where trading back becomes not just an option but a strategy that aligns with roster construction, depth-building, and sustained success.
The Titans are not a one-player fix.
They need help along the offensive line, more consistent playmakers on offense, and defensive pieces that can impact the quarterback in a conference loaded with elite talent.
Moving back into the middle of the first round allows Tennessee to remain in position for high-level prospects while also gaining the flexibility to attack multiple needs early in the draft.
Reestablishing the Offensive Line Identity
We will start with the “bigs”.
The identity of the Titans has historically been built on physicality, particularly in the trenches. That foundation has been inconsistent in recent seasons, directly impacting both the run game and pass protection. If Tennessee moves back, getting an extra second-round pick and targeting a player like Chase Bisontis could be a logical and impactful decision. His strength at the point of attack and ability to generate movement in the run game would immediately bring a different tone to the offense. This is not just about improving statistics. It is about restoring an identity that allows the entire offensive system to function more efficiently.
If not, they could look to tackle Tristan Leigh later on in the draft. Especially if they move JC Latham inside.
Leigh presents a different type of value. He is not necessarily the most polished player in this range, but his physical traits and developmental upside are exactly what teams look for in long-term solutions. For a Titans team that has struggled with consistency on the edge, investing in a high-upside tackle provides both immediate depth and future stability.
Adding a Reliable Offensive Playmaker
If the Titans choose to prioritize skill position talent, the conversation shifts toward adding a wide receiver who can consistently produce. Carnell Tate, Omar Cooper Jr., and Makai Lemon fit that description. These are not just explosive athletes but also refined route runners who understand spacing, timing, and leverage.
For an offense that has struggled to create separation and sustain drives, each of these guys offer a level of reliability that translates immediately. He becomes the type of target a quarterback can trust in critical situations, which is something Tennessee has lacked.
Now, I must admit, I do not want to draft a wide receiver this early. So, this option must come if we decide to trade back.
Disrupting the Modern AFC Offense
Defensively, the priority remains clear.
If you cannot pressure the quarterback or hold up in coverage, you cannot compete consistently in today’s NFL. Rueben Bain Jr. brings the kind of relentless energy and physicality that translates to immediate production. His ability to impact both the run and pass game makes him more than just a situational rusher. He becomes a foundational piece of the defensive front.
On the back end, Mansoor Delane provides the length, confidence, and physical style that fit Tennessee’s defensive philosophy. In a division and conference where passing attacks are evolving rapidly, having corners who can compete in man coverage without constant safety help is critical. Delane gives the Titans that flexibility.
I personally love David Bailey Jr., but he might not be there at the 4th spot.
Turning One Pick Into Multiple Contributors
The real advantage of trading back becomes evident in Round 2.
Instead of leaving the early portion of the draft with a single player, Tennessee could position itself to add another contributor who can fill a key role immediately. This is where roster construction shifts from top-heavy to balanced, a shift that is essential for long-term success.
Offensive Line Depth
Cam Ward is a star. But he must stay upright and healthy. He was sacked 55 times last season. That cannot and should not happen again.
Even if the Titans address the offensive line in Round 1, reinforcing the unit again in Round 2 creates competition and depth. Austin Barber offers a high floor with experience against top-tier competition. He may not carry elite upside, but his consistency makes him a viable option to compete for playing time early in his career.
James Brockermeyer adds another layer of value through versatility.
His ability to play multiple interior positions gives Tennessee flexibility in managing injuries and lineup changes. This is how teams build resilient offensive lines rather than relying on a single solution. Now, he’s a projected Day 3 pick. So, obviously, I do not want him early. But he could add much-needed depth to our offensive line.
Creating Depth in the Pass Rush
A successful defense cannot rely on one player to generate pressure. It requires depth and rotation. Zion Young brings the physical tools and developmental upside to fit into that rotation early while growing into a larger role over time.
Inside, Caleb Banks provides strength and disruption in the interior. His presence helps collapse the pocket and creates opportunities for edge rushers to finish plays. These are the types of additions that do not always generate headlines but are essential for defensive success.
Adding Explosiveness to the Offense
I want to start off by saying that I think Jeremiyah Love could be great for the Titans, but no pun intended, I do not want him with the 4 spot. It just does not make sense for value and cap allocation.
The Titans do need players who can create explosive plays without relying on perfect execution. And, Jeremiyah Love brings that element. His acceleration, vision, and ability to turn limited space into significant gains give Tennessee a different dimension offensively. He is the type of player who forces defenses to adjust, which opens opportunities for the rest of the offense.
A Smarter Path Forward for Tennessee
For the Tennessee Titans, the decision at No. 4 is not just about selecting a player. It is about maximizing value. If the right prospect is not there, moving back allows the organization to build across multiple positions, add depth, and create competition throughout the roster.
This approach is not about playing it safe. It is about being strategic. By turning one premium pick into multiple high-value selections, Tennessee positions itself to improve immediately while also building a foundation for sustained success. In a conference where depth, versatility, and playmaking determine outcomes, that may be the difference between staying competitive and truly contending.
Thank you to our sponsors!
Leave a Reply